> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.theredoubt.net/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The real problem with immigration in Europe
- URL: https://www.theredoubt.net/the-real-problem-with-immigration-in-europe/
- Published: 2026-11-19T14:12:16.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-19T14:12:16.000Z
- Description: Few politicians are willing to admit — publicly — that their countries need a lot more new arrivals.
- Author: Charles R. Davis
- Tags: analysis, news

VIENNA — Allow me to be abundantly clear: I do not advocate direct, unaccountable rule by a cabal of technocratic bankers, nor do I believe the masses are incapable of self-governance. But looking around at the state of politics in Europe, it can be tempting to view the undemocratic alternative with a touch of longing.

Across the continent, it is taken as a given — in the world of politics — that immigration is a "problem" that can only be fixed by reducing it. Even centrist and some social democratic parties have cosigned the right-wing narrative about a flood of undesirable human beings making Europe worse by trying to live in it.

[Subscribe to The Redoubt](#/portal/signup)

The problem is so grave, the status quo so untenable, that at a migration conference held in Vienna this week, five European countries (Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands) announced a deal to deport rejected asylum-seekers to Rwanda, whether or not that is from where they came.

Americans may recognize this as the U.S. government's [policy](https://prospect.org/2026/10/23/trump-administration-may-have-just-lied-to-judge-about-ice-flight-to-equatorial-guinea/?ref=theredoubt.net) under President Donald Trump: putting shackled immigrants on planes and paying African nations to take them when their countries of origin will not. European nations are taking some steps to appear kinder and gentler: those sent to the new deportation "hub" in Rwanda will receive language and other training for "a few weeks" to help them integrate into local society, [according to Reuters](https://www.usnews.com/news/world/articles/2026-11-17/explainer-five-eu-countries-plan-for-a-deportation-hub-in-rwanda?ref=theredoubt.net). But for those being sent against their will to somewhere they have never been, it's hard to say the material reality will be that different.

As the news coverage notes, the motivation is essentially the same in Europe as in America: to perform an act of cruelty, and mostly for domestic consumption. The ostensible purpose is to discourage other, unworthy asylum-seekers, but truth be told: "Domestic ​politics also plays an important role, since the countries involved are led by centrist parties struggling not to lose more ground to far-right parties campaigning against ​illegal immigration."

[EU building 'Fortress Europe' with harsher new asylum regimeThe new "Common European Asylum System" comes at a time when immigration is already falling.![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/f6/71/f671d086-f0d7-4c0f-bc4c-d72fa949f40c/content/images/icon/The-Redoubt-19--1-a70feccb-e19b-4d93-a806-95c4ea6d3dd4.png)The RedoubtCharles R. Davis![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/f6/71/f671d086-f0d7-4c0f-bc4c-d72fa949f40c/content/images/thumbnail/IMG_8222-7603cb41-62e3-4707-a5bc-835556282fb7.jpg)](https://www.theredoubt.net/in-a-concession-to-the-far-right-the-eu-tries-to-build-fortress-europe/)

What just about no one in politics will admit is that Europe's actual problem with immigration is that there isn't enough of it. Peaking with the war in Syria, the number of new people coming to Europe has been declining for years. That decline has not eliminated the threat posed by the far right, however, because guess what? Far-right voters are not looking at statistics when they decide there are too many foreigners; they are consuming rage-bait on social media — and artificial intelligence means there will always be a steady stream of content depicting immigrants behaving badly (or existing in public).

At the same time, Europe, with a below-replacement rate of birth, is damaging its own long-term interests in the mistaken belief that anti-immigrant politics are linked to the actual number of immigrants or the policies that govern them. Europe's squishy centrists and middling social democrats, by ceding the narrative to their opponents, are feeding the monster. 

It's not a coincidence that the decline in new arrivals to Europe has been accompanied by calls for "[remigration](https://www.theredoubt.net/afd-republican-remigration-summit/)" by the far-right AfD in Germany and FPÖ in Austria — unfiltered, a demand for ethnic cleansing via the deportation of not just recent immigrants, but the descendants of those who came decades before. There will never be a point where those who hate the sight of someone different will conclude that the problem has been solved.

The reality that Europe clearly needs more people, not fewer — and that this means more babies or more immigrants, and people aren't having more babies — is rarely admitted in polite society, where the consensus remains that the problem with immigration is that it must be "controlled" to the liking of the loudest xenophobes.

[Europe's far right has a new target: newborn babiesAustria's neo-fascist FPÖ is demanding that the government stop helping immigrants start families.![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/f6/71/f671d086-f0d7-4c0f-bc4c-d72fa949f40c/content/images/icon/The-Redoubt-19--1-fbab38ee-2385-4de7-b2ee-5ede981731cb.png)The RedoubtCharles R. Davis![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/f6/71/f671d086-f0d7-4c0f-bc4c-d72fa949f40c/content/images/thumbnail/photo-1513091250092-b06c2b7981bc-ac593b47-fc73-45a2-b544-2c8994cd61a9.jpg)](https://www.theredoubt.net/europes-far-right-has-a-new-target-newborn-babies/)

At a Nov. 18 briefing for foreign press, including *The Redoubt*, Martin Kocher, governor of the Austrian National Bank, did not explicitly blame Europe's anti-immigrant politics for its economic troubles. But the behavioral economist, speaking on the state of Europe's economy, did observe the obvious: that despite all the rhetoric about a "flood" of immigration, Europe is actually suffering from having too few people.

"Ten years ago, a good part of \[economic\] growth was growth of the working population," Kocher, speaking in German, told reporters, referencing a time when new arrivals were at their peak. "Now we no longer have any growth of the working population in most European countries," he said. "That means lower growth rates ... \[and\] that simply has to do with population developments."

Take Austria, which is one of Europe's wealthiest nations and also, now, economically stagnant. In 2025, the working-age population did not contract for [two reasons](https://www.theredoubt.net/in-a-concession-to-the-far-right-the-eu-tries-to-build-fortress-europe/): immigration, and the Austrian government raising the retirement age for women.

Real & independent journalism 

This original reporting is funded entirely by readers like you — not governments, and not corporations. Support us with a [paid subscription](https://www.theredoubt.net/#/portal/signup) or [one-time donation](https://www.theredoubt.net/#/portal/support).

[Join The Redoubt ](#/portal/signup) 

Fewer working-age immigrants also means fewer people available to take care of Europe's growing number of elderly citizens, which in turn increases the cost of that care.

"Clearly that leaves fewer resources to boost growth," Kocher said. A population that skews older is also less likely to grow the economy with innovation, he continued, "because aging societies are generally less dynamic."

From a progressive standpoint, innovation and economic dynamism are not the most satisfying arguments for allowing people to live and build a life wherever they like, so long as they are not harming the equal right of others to do the same. But someone does have to say it: that beyond being a moral travesty, Europe's efforts to restrict immigration are making the continent worse off — economically, as well as culturally — than it could be.

Far-right demagogues and their imitators love to imagine themselves as uttering unspeakable truths. But how many politicians in Europe will say that the continent's biggest problem is that there are too few immigrants, not too many?

## Sign up for The Redoubt

Independent reporting, original analysis, democratic values.

Subscribe 

Email sent! Check your inbox to complete your signup. 

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.